Faction Reviews and Ratings.... Submit now!

[ElimiNator]

Criteria for ratings:

0-5% New Models
0-5% Good Models
0-5% New Textures
0-5% Good Textures
0-5% New Animations
0-5% Good Animations
0-5% New Sounds
0-5% Good Sounds
0-5% New Music
0-5% Good Music
0-5% New Icons
0-5% Good Icons
0-10% AI
0-5% New Particles
0-5% Good Particles
0-10% Balance
0-10% Gameplay
=0-100% overall rating

platinum:  95 pt
Gold:       75 pt
Silver:     55 pt
Bronze:    35 pt
Stone:     25 pt
wood       0 pt

[-Archmage-]

Elim, criteria is on the first post.

[-Archmage-]

MegaPack Review:

9%   Models                     -Mostly original, and very well done models
10% Textures                  -Amazing textures
7%   Animations               -Animations aren't very realistic looking, but otherwise they are reasonable well done
7%   Sounds                    -Some are original and some aren't, the original sounds are good and the copied ones fit in fine
9%   Music                      -The music is good and each fits it's faction well, but in my opinion it could be slightly better for a 10.
8%   Icons                      -The icons are good, but as I recall the theme seems to be a little inconsistent in some factions
10% AI                           -The AI plays fine
8%  Particles                   -The particles are good, but they could use improvement.
8%  Balance                    -There is slight imbalance amongst the factions
9%  Miscellaneous            -Gameplay is very enjoyable

85% Overall Rating - GOLD

[ElimiNator]

Who made that?...

[-Archmage-]

Who made that?...

What are you talking about?

[ElimiNator]

MegaPack Review:

9%   Models                     -Mostly original, and very well done models
10% Textures                  -Amazing textures
7%   Animations               -Animations aren't very realistic looking, but otherwise they are reasonable well done
7%   Sounds                    -Some are original and some aren't, the original sounds are good and the copied ones fit in fine
9%   Music                      -The music is good and each fits it's faction well, but in my opinion it could be slightly better for a 10.
8%   Icons                      -The icons are good, but as I recall the theme seems to be a little inconsistent in some factions
10% AI                           -The AI plays fine
8%  Particles                   -The particles are good, but they could use improvement.
8%  Balance                    -There is slight imbalance amongst the factions
9%  Miscellaneous            -Gameplay is very enjoyable

85% Overall Rating - GOLD

Who made this, you? could you rate Tigers:

I need some one to rate whimsical forest mod,

Rate it with this criteria.

Archmge, John, Titi, ultifd, or omega.

And Vbros if you have got time?

[-Archmage-]

Quote from: -Archmage- on August 27, 2010, 11:12:57
MegaPack Review:

9%   Models                     -Mostly original, and very well done models
10% Textures                  -Amazing textures
7%   Animations               -Animations aren't very realistic looking, but otherwise they are reasonable well done
7%   Sounds                    -Some are original and some aren't, the original sounds are good and the copied ones fit in fine
9%   Music                      -The music is good and each fits it's faction well, but in my opinion it could be slightly better for a 10.
8%   Icons                      -The icons are good, but as I recall the theme seems to be a little inconsistent in some factions
10% AI                           -The AI plays fine
8%  Particles                   -The particles are good, but they could use improvement.
8%  Balance                    -There is slight imbalance amongst the factions
9%  Miscellaneous            -Gameplay is very enjoyable

85% Overall Rating - GOLD
Who made this, you?

Yea.


I don't think I've played the latest versions of VBros and Whimsical Forest...

[ElimiNator]

Why don't you try them?

[Omega]

Hmm, and while we're at it, why not rate military? It's in need of a rating and nobody has done it yet for any version, though I specifically would like the new version rated.

[-Archmage-]

Why don't you try them?

Well, to be frank, MW2 is a lot more fun, and whenever I'm not playing MW2, I'm either hanging out, lying around, or doing something else. I just don't play Glest much...

Hmm, and while we're at it, why not rate military? It's in need of a rating and nobody has done it yet for any version, though I specifically would like the new version rated.

Well, the last version I played was 2.1....... And I didn't play it much...... No offense.

[ElimiNator]

Then why do you come on the forums? And what is MW2?

[-Archmage-]

Then why do you come on the forums?

1: I have a responsibility as a moderator.
2: You guys are cool.
3: I do 3D Art for people on the forums.
4: And more...

And what is MW2?

MW2: Modern Warfare 2
Call of Duty 4/7: Modern Warfare 2

But let's not get talking about this...

[ultifd]

So you won't try because there are other similar and better games, and after that you're busy. 2nd part seems fine, but first part? Hmm...
I guess I might review Military if I have time, but after it updates to the future GAE 0.3 . 

[-Archmage-]

So you won't try because there are other similar and better games

MW2 is a first-person shooter. It's nothing like Glest...

I don't have much to do tomorrow... I guess I could play a game of Glest......

[ultifd]

Yes it is... I was referring to it being similar to Military since...Military style of MW2 is similar...just the essence of Military...nevermind. guess I should have been more specific.
Anyways, whatever... if there is a review of Military now it'll probably need another review for Military w/ GAE 3.0 . Unless if that is a long time for now... Hmm...